In that way, while we do not know if this Strasburg-mania will last – or if he will suddenly implode and look real – we do have history to tell us that there have been pitchers that have received this response before.
Unfortunately most of those pitchers do drop off the earth suddenly.
Strasburg then best needs to be compared to his peers before him - exciting young pitchers that burst onto the big league scene to start their careers.
None better to compare with than Dwight (Doc) Gooden when he appeared with the New York Mets starting rotation in 1984.
Gooden and his 98 mph pitches were good enough to make him at 19 years old the youngest player ever on an All-Star team.
That season he had 17 wins which was exceptional for his age and so fans would show up just to watch him.
In 1984 he won eight of his last nine decisions but there was a noteworthy ending with his three final starts that season. Over those last three appearances Gooden struck out 41 batters and walked only one.
Gooden led the league in strikeouts that season with 284.
Gooden was even better in 1985 when he became the youngest Cy Young Award winner.
That season Gooden had 24 wins, 268 strike outs and a 1.53 ERA.
They say he even dominated in the nine games he lost that season – I guess he didn’t get much run support some nights.
They say that from 1983-1985 there was a stretch where Gooden threw 10800 pitches. From August 1984 to May 1986 he made 50 starts and posted a 37-5 record with a 1.40 ERA and 412 strike outs (and surrendered only 90 walks).
Obviously some off-field drug and alcohol issues caught up with Gooden but for those first few years he was worth going to the park to watch.
Another pitching start that got some of the attention like Strasburg is quickly receiving was the 1976 debut of Mark “the Bird” Fidrych.
That season people went to see Fidrych pitch, but not necessarily to watch his team, the Detroit Tigers, play. The Tigers were terrible, but Fidrych went 19-9 and had a 2.34 ERA.
At only 22 years old Fidrych with funny mannerisms on the mound was like a circus for the curious to come and see...and he was winning.
Fidrych was named Rookie of the Year that season.
Unfortunately for all of us, after 1976 Fidrych was just an average pitcher on a poor team and his career did not last past 1980.
Also I remember the late 1970s for J.R. Richard of the Houston Astros who was a tall lanky powerful pitcher, a bit wild though, that also captured attention.
Richard was a bit older by the time he was something you did not want to miss at your local National League ballpark.
His career blossomed in 1977 when he became 27.
Over a two year span Richard became one of only three pitchers ever (Nolan Ryan and Sandy Koufax the others) to strike out 300 hitters in back to back seasons. In fact 319 strike outs in 1979 is still an Astros record.
Richard had a nine year pro career, but he spent much of his formative years in the minors.
The Astros were contenders and he was contributing, albeit in the shadow of the great Nolan Ryan.
Some have inferred that Ryan despised Richard perhaps for taking attention from him – and competing with him. It was Richard though who perhaps could not handle the pressure of being paid significantly less than Ryan because he was on Ryan’s team and Ryan was the Astros main meal ticket.
In 1980 Richard suffered a stroke prior to a game and never returned to a level of prominence, retiring shortly after.
One of the most charismatic and followed pitchers though from his first start in 1981 has to be Fernando “El Toro” Valenzuela.
If any pitcher burst onto the scene and created a following that has lasted even after he left it is he.
Could have been because he could not speak a word of English when he started in Los Angeles Dodgers blue?
Could have been because he is Mexican, and there are lots of Latinos that follow baseball and that live in Southern California that instantly became Dodger fans?
Not lost in that today is that baseball has created a whole Spanish broadcasting and marketing presence and now so many Latino players have since followed the Valenzuela path to prominence in the league.
What Valenzuela did when he got his start, perhaps like Strasburg is about to, is start well. In fact entire career numbers aside Valenzuela started better than anyone could imagine.
Yet for Valenzuela he was only really great for his first eight starts in the league.
At 21 years old Valenzuela not only won his first eight games he had a microscopic 0.50 ERA through those eight starts in a season where not only did huge crowds come out to see him, but his team ended up winning a World Series.
Valenzuela had mass appeal and it earned him a Cy Young Award, Rookie of the Year Award, and a spot on the roster again in 1982.
However with El Toro it is likely the shortened season and interruption caused by the 1981 player’s strike that broke his momentum.
Valenzuela was OK after that but not great like he was in April and May.
So now that Strasburg has his cleats muddy with dirt from the hill of a Major League park which path will his career take from here?
Eventually teams around the league will get a look at him and hitters will get a book on him. That we know. How will he respond?
The Nationals are not in a hurry to make him their ace, but the pressure will be on them to do so. They will be under a microscope for every decision they make with Strasburg.
They will be accused of pushing to fast and wearing him out, or letting him cool and break his regimen by not exposing him enough to big league hitters.
These other pitchers I mentioned all had things that stained over the sparkling gleams they started with, and we just do not know what if any of those career killers will happen with this prospect, and neither do the Nationals so excuse them if they become over protective of their asset.
Right now what Strasburg has done for sure has cemented his beginning, as he will certainly be forever remembered as the guy who struck out 14 batters in his first Major League start.
Only time will tell though, what this guy will be doing next spring, or the autumn after that or two more seasons later.
It’s nice to hope that we get to see more of this though.
For the time being though, if you, like me, were sleeping through the lead up to Strasburg’s last start I doubt you will stray too far from the highlight reel show after his next one.